Thursday, February 23, 2012

Misfires & Light Strikes

Minimize
Aug 22

Written by: misfiresadmin
8/22/2011 8:34 AM 

"Among the factors determining murder rates, levels of gun ownership is among the most overstated and least reliable... 'There is no empirical support for the claim that gun ownership is related to violence rates'.” 

Sounds like a typical NRA quote, right? 

Wrong.

Not is the source of this quote a Canadian academic, it's a Canadian academic being quoted in Maclean's, the mainstream media newsmagazine of choice for the Canadian political elite. 

More juicy quotes: 

"In fact, neither assumption is on the mark. A look at Canada, in the context of international crime statistics and the factors behind them, yields some myth-busting results. More guns, for instance, don’t always equate to higher murder rates. Nor are the streets necessarily safer with more police on the street and more bad guys in jail."

"We (Canadians) have fewer police per capita than about 80 per cent of the world, yet a murder rate lower than Scotland."

"Canadians have more firepower—31 guns for every 100 civilians—than South Africa (13 per 100) Jamaica (8 per 100) or Columbia (six per 100), where murder rates surpass Canada by as much as 20-times or more. Americans are among the best-armed civilians on earth with some 89 firearms per 100 people. Their availability makes them the weapon of choice in 68 per cent of American homicides, and yet even in the U.S. murder rates have been falling." 

The next time somebody tells you we should have more "common sense" gun laws like other countries have, point them to this article and watch their heads explode. 

Tags:

3 comment(s) so far...

Re: Numbers Game

Awesome. I'll have to bookmark that for the debate I'll be having with the Canadian in-laws next year.

By 45er on   8/22/2011 8:18 PM

Re: Numbers Game

It may be counter intuitive, especially to the anti gun crowd, but it's not about the number of guns, it's about who has them. When guns are in the hands of honest citizens it is for the most part a safer society. Switzerland is the classic example. Every adult male is issued a military weapon, trained in its use, and keeps it in his home. When extreme gun control disarms the common people criminals still seem to find weapons and delight in the disarmed condition of their victims. And Mexico with it's highly restrictive gun control would be the poster child for that case where armed violence by the criminal element is rampant.
Easy availability of firearms does increase certain risks, just as does the presence of automobiles and other dangerous power tools, but those risks are countered by the benefits inherent in the ability for armed self defense.

By Uncle Lar on   8/24/2011 8:38 AM

Re: Numbers Game

Heh.

"... Maclean's, the mainstream media newsmagazine of choice for the Canadian political elite."

I find this story even more astonishing, as I remember Maclean's as the magazine which in a story about U.S. gun-control misquoted the text of the U.S. constitution's 2nd Amendment.

Maclean's text read, "A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free State, the right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed." Notably the Maclean's text omitted the phrase "of the People", as the actual correct text of the 2nd Amendment reads, "A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the People to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed."

Maclean's had changed "... the right of the People to keep and bear arms ..." into "... the right to keep and bear arms ..."! Not surprisingly, the point of the Maclean's article was that the 2nd Amendment did not protect an individual right to arms, because the 2nd Amendment only related to the power of States to have a militia. No doubt the mangling of "the right of the People" made that case easier to make.

I suppose cognitive dissonance spoils the digestion of the political elite. Can't have that. It's bad for the advertisers.

By Brad on   8/25/2011 11:07 PM

Your name:
Your email:
(Optional) Email used only to show Gravatar.
Your website:
Title:
Comment:
Security Code
Enter the code shown above in the box below
Add Comment   Cancel 
Sponsored by

Gunsmithing supplies, rifle accessories, and more

Brownells

NRA Firearms Classes

NRA Firearms Classes

Online Firearms Sales

Online Firearms Sales

AR-15 and M-1 Garand Gunsmithing

AR-15 and M-1 Garand Gunsmithing

Commerce Clause
Front Sight Class Review Series
Learn to shoot

If you've never shot a gun and want to learn what the the Second Amendment is REALLY all about, I'm more than willing to help.

I'll provide the firearms, ammunition and safety gear, all you need to do is show up and have a good time.

Not in Arizona?

No problem. Mulligan has a handy-dandy Google map list of people like myself all over the country who are willing to help you learn what the shooting sports are all about.

More info

RSS RSS Feed

Contact me: Kevin (at) exurbanleague.com 

Follow me on Twitter: @ExurbanKevin

Exurbanleague.com Home Page 

Public Range in Mesa Arizona Phoenix IDPA Club Arizona Firearms Training

Mesa Arizona Indoor Shooting Range

Arizona State Rifle and Pistol Association

Gun Up ; The Future of Guns Online

A gun forum for experts

BlogBash

Friends and Neighbors
Search Blog
Recent Entries
Archives